Top 6 compared
The best bird feeders
Blue tits, goldfinches and sparrows coming to the garden every day, close enough to watch from the kitchen window.
92 checked · 6 made the cut
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. It costs you nothing extra. How this works
The top 6 at a glance
A bird feeder hangs from a branch, a hook or a pole and holds food where the birds can reach it. Tube feeders with perches take seed; mesh feeders hold peanuts, and small cages fat balls; squirrel-proof ones use a cage or ports that shut under a squirrel; window feeders stick to the glass; a feeding station is a pole with hooks for several, for a garden with no tree.
Metal lasts and squirrels chew plastic, so steel and aluminium suit a garden they visit, and a squirrel-proof design is for one where they’ve already won. Hang a feeder near a bush or tree, so small birds have cover to dart back to, but beyond a squirrel’s leap.
What matters
- Easy to fill: a wide twist-off lid, one-handed.
- Comes apart for a wash in hot soapy water every fortnight.
- Drainage holes, so seed doesn’t sit damp and go mouldy.
- Match the feeder to the food: seed, nyjer, peanuts or suet.

#1PROVIDE Heavy-Duty Steel Seed Feeder (6 ports)
£20–£30
- Six feeding ports
- Large twist-off lid
- Seed-catching tray
A big twist-off lid makes filling quick, and a ring round the base gives birds somewhere steady to stand while a tray catches some of the dropped seed. Six ports with large pegs mean several birds can feed at once.
What owners say: Owners call it well constructed and simple to fill and hang, and like that it holds enough to go a while between refills; some say squirrels leave it alone, others that they don’t.
A closer look: It takes black sunflower seed, sunflower hearts and mixed seed only, so peanuts and mealworms need a feeder of their own. A guide printed on the side shows how the lid comes off, which saves a fumble with cold fingers on a winter morning.
Best for: Easy filling
- Type
- Seed tube, 6 ports
- Size
- 36 × 14cm
- Takes
- Sunflower hearts, mixed seed
- Squirrel-proof design
- No

#2BPYOT Window Bird Feeder with Suction Cups
£10–£20
- No tree or pole needed
- Seed tray lifts out
A clear acrylic feeder that sticks to the outside of a window, so robins and tits feed right up against the glass: no garden, tree or pole needed. The seed tray lifts out for refilling and cleaning without taking the feeder off the window.
What owners say: Owners say small birds, robins especially, find it quickly, and that the suction cups hold firm even in strong winds; they find it sturdy, easy to put up and good to look at.
A closer look: Clean the glass with a little washing-up liquid and let it dry before pressing the cups on, as they grip best on a smooth, grease-free pane. Birds can take a week or two to trust a new feeder this close to a house, so leave it in one spot while they get used to it.
Best for: Feeding at the window
- Type
- Window feeder with tray
- Size
- 26.5 × 20cm
- Takes
- Seed
- Squirrel-proof design
- No

#3Supa Fat Ball Feeder with Tray
Under £10
- Tray doubles as feeding table
- All-metal build
An all-metal feeder for fat balls, netted or un-netted, with a tray underneath that doubles as a little feeding table and catches the crumbs before they reach the ground and draw rats. Robins, wrens, starlings and blue tits all come to fat balls.
What owners say: Owners rate its quality and say birds flock to it, with the tray catching what they drop, and call it solid and simple to use.
A closer look: Take fat balls out of their nets before they go in, as the mesh can trap small birds’ feet and beaks. Tip out and scrub the tray every week or so, as fat crumbs left in it in warm weather turn rancid.
Best for: Feeding fat balls
- Type
- Fat ball feeder with tray
- Size
- 26cm tall
- Takes
- Fat balls, netted or not
- Squirrel-proof design
- No

#4PROVIDE Squirrel-Proof Seed Feeder (spring-loaded ports)
£20–£30
- Ports shut under squirrels, pigeons
- Holds about 800g of seed
- Base twists off, no tools
When a squirrel, pigeon or rat lands on a perch, its weight closes the ports, so the seed stays for tits and finches. The base twists off for cleaning with no tools, and a metal leaf over each port gives it a softer look in a border.
What owners say: Owners describe it as solid, with metal perches that don’t rot in the sun, find the removable base makes cleaning quick, and say it keeps squirrels off; they like its size and looks.
A closer look: Put it where you can see it from a window, and you can watch the ports snap shut when a pigeon tries its luck. They only close when something lands, so hang it from the clasp on its lid well clear of any ledge or branch a squirrel could reach the seed from.
Best for: Keeping squirrels off
- Type
- Seed tube, spring-loaded ports
- Size
- 38 × 14cm
- Takes
- Sunflower seed, seed mix
- Squirrel-proof design
- Spring-loaded ports

#5Gardman Heavy Duty Peanut Feeder
£10–£20
- Comes fully apart to clean
- Antibacterial feed-safe coating
- All-metal cast-aluminium body
A polished cast-aluminium mesh feeder for whole peanuts from Gardman’s heavy-duty range. It comes fully apart for cleaning and has a feed-safe coating that Gardman says kills bacteria on contact, and it holds about 270g of nuts.
What owners say: Owners like its heavy build and silver finish, say it holds up well and is easy to fill and clean, but disagree about whether squirrels can raid it.
A closer look: A mesh feeder makes birds peck small pieces off a peanut rather than carry off a whole nut, which matters most in spring, when whole nuts can choke nestlings. Fill it little and often in wet spells so the nuts don’t sit damp for days.
Best for: Feeding peanuts
- Type
- Mesh peanut feeder
- Size
- 23cm tall
- Takes
- Whole peanuts (about 270g)
- Squirrel-proof design
- No

#6MIXXIDEA Bird Feeding Station Kit
£20–£30
- Six hooks for feeders
- Water bath included
- Feeders for seed, peanuts and suet
A tall pole with six hooks, feeders, a suet cage and a water bath: a whole bird café for a lawn with no handy tree. It makes a centrepiece to watch from the window.
What owners say: Owners say it brings the birds in and like its looks and the price, but some report rust within a few months and poles snapping in storms.
A closer look: Push the five-prong base well into soft ground, and take the heaviest feeders off the top hooks before a forecast gale, when the pole is under most strain. Keep the water bath topped up in winter: birds still need to drink and bathe when it’s cold.
Best for: Free standing
- Type
- Feeding station with pole
- Size
- About 2.25m tall
- Takes
- Seed, peanuts, suet, water
- Squirrel-proof design
- No
Side by side
How they compare
Swipe sideways or rotate device to see all 6.
| Feature | #1PROVIDE 6-port | #2BPYOT window feeder | #3Supa fat ball feeder | #4PROVIDE squirrel-proof | #5Gardman peanut feeder | #6MIXXIDEA station |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best overall | Best budget | |||||
| Picked Rating | 9.3 | 9.2 | 9.0 | 9.0 | 8.9 | 8.9 |
| Price | £20–£30 | £10–£20 | Under £10 | £20–£30 | £10–£20 | £20–£30 |
| Type | Seed tube, 6 ports | Window feeder with tray | Fat ball feeder with tray | Seed tube, spring-loaded ports | Mesh peanut feeder | Feeding station with pole |
| Size | 36 × 14cm | 26.5 × 20cm | 26cm tall | 38 × 14cm | 23cm tall | About 2.25m tall |
| Takes | Sunflower hearts, mixed seed | Seed | Fat balls, netted or not | Sunflower seed, seed mix | Whole peanuts (about 270g) | Seed, peanuts, suet, water |
| Squirrel-proof design | No | No | No | Spring-loaded ports | No | No |
| Best for | Easy filling | Feeding at the window | Feeding fat balls | Keeping squirrels off | Feeding peanuts | Free standing |
| Buy now | Amazon | Amazon | Amazon | Amazon | Amazon | Amazon |
How we checked these
How 92 became 6
We found 92 bird feeder listings. Four were the same feeder listed again, and 59 were rated too low and/or had too few ratings or sales to compete. That left 29, which we narrowed down step by step:
- Ratings, reviews and salesFor the 29, we then checked the ratings and reviews further, and how many people buy each one. Owners talked most about squirrels, then how long they last, the lids and whether birds use them. After these checks, we dropped four more.25 left
- Features weighed upThe 25 left were compared on feeder type, the food each takes and whether it is built to keep squirrels out. Once everything was weighed up together, we dropped 19 more. The #1 has every feature you’d expect from a bird feeder.6 made the cut
- Value for moneyEvery bird feeder here is worth what it costs. A dearer one is only here if it gives you more.
Spotted a mistake or something out of date? Tell usBack to top





