Top 6 compared
The best colouring pencils
Rich, smooth colour for adult colouring books and children’s drawings, shaded and blended with a light touch.
29 checked · 6 made the cut
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. It costs you nothing extra. How this works
The top 6 at a glance
Colouring pencils are an easy way into colour: pick one up and start, with nothing to mix or wait to dry. Packs for children are tough and easy to grip, while bigger sets with dozens of shades, including metallics and neons, are made for detailed mandalas and nature pages and for blending one shade into the next.
Some sets come in a metal tin, a zipped case or a box that folds into a stand, which keeps the shades in order. Artists’ pencils with oil-based leads cost more but layer and blend further, and a colouring book in the set means something to colour from the first evening. Woodless pencils, with a resin barrel instead of wood, don’t splinter if they snap.
What matters
- Leads that lay down colour without pressing hard.
- Break-resistant leads, especially for children.
- No duplicate shades in a big set.

#1Faber-Castell Classic Colour Pencils (60 colours)
£22.95 RRP
- 60 colours in one set
- Neon, metallic and pastel shades
- Box folds into a stand
Sixty colours, including neons, metallics and pastels, in a box that folds out into a stand so every shade is in view. Children and grown-ups alike can use it, so it goes first; the two higher scorers are the Polychromos, an artists’ step up, and the BIC, a children’s pack.
What owners say: Owners love the choice of shades and how easily they blend, and find them soft and smooth for mandalas and colouring books. Breakage splits them: some find the leads hold up, others say they snap when sharpened.
A closer look: For smooth, even colour, build up two or three light layers rather than pressing hard once. Metallic pencils stand out best on dark paper, so save them for black pages or final highlights. Try each new colour in the margin first, as some look darker on the page than on the barrel.
Best for: Metallics
- Colours
- 60, incl. neon, metallic, pastel
- Comes in
- Stand-up box
- Extras
- None

#2Faber-Castell Polychromos Artists’ Colour Pencils (tin of 24)
£30–£50
- Thick 3.8mm oil-based leads
- Lightfast, water-resistant colour
- Comes in a metal tin
Faber-Castell’s artist-grade pencils: thick 3.8mm oil-based leads that lay down soft, strong colour, resist water and smudging, and are made to be lightfast. Twenty-four is a starter tin from a range of 120 colours, so the set can grow.
What owners say: Owners rate them as top quality, with vivid, long-lasting colours that blend and layer beautifully and a smooth, buttery feel, and find them good enough for fine art work.
A closer look: Work in small, light circles rather than straight strokes for the smoothest finish, as circles hide the pencil lines. Keep the tin flat in a drawer between sessions, so the pencils stay in their slots and the points don’t knock together.
Best for: Artists
- Colours
- 24 (artist grade)
- Comes in
- Metal tin
- Extras
- None

#3BIC Kids Evolution ECOlutions Colouring Pencils (24 colours)
Under £10
- Woodless resin barrel
- Chew-resistant barrel
- Hexagonal, won’t roll away
Woodless pencils with a chew-resistant resin barrel that doesn’t splinter if one snaps, and thick 3.05mm leads for strong coverage. They’re made for children from 5 and built for school bags.
What owners say: Vibrant colours and smooth leads that glide on paper please owners, who find they sharpen well, are easy to use and suit children.
A closer look: Give younger children a few colours at a time rather than all 24, which keeps them focused and the pack complete. Counting the pencils back into the pack at the end of each session is a habit that saves hunting for lost colours later.
Best for: No splinters
- Colours
- 24
- Comes in
- –
- Extras
- None

#4Melifluo 73-Piece Colouring Pencils with a Colouring Book
£10–£20
- 72 colours in one set
- Zipped case, slot per pencil
- Includes a colouring book
Seventy-two pencils and a colouring book to start on, in a zipped case with a slot for every pencil, so the shades stay in order and the set travels well.
What owners say: Owners find it good quality with a wide variety of vivid shades and like the case. The pencils blend well and sharpen easily, though some have leads breaking as they sharpen.
A closer look: Pick three or four shades of one colour and practise moving from light to dark across a single shape: it’s the quickest way to learn blending. Smooth paper works best, as textured paper leaves white flecks that soft leads struggle to fill. Sharpen slowly with a sharp blade, as the leads can break while they’re being sharpened.
Best for: Colouring book in the box
- Colours
- 72
- Comes in
- Zipped case
- Extras
- Colouring book

#5Crayola Colouring Pencils (24 colours)
Under £10
- Break-resistant leads
- Suitable for young children
- Card pack, no case
Chunky 3.3mm leads that lay down colour without white gaps, from the brand that has been making children’s colouring things since 1903. Made for ages 3 and up, with soft leads that colour without pressing hard.
What owners say: Owners like the 24 colours and how smoothly they colour, find them good for school, and say toddlers love them. Durability and sharpening get mixed reports, with some leads breaking.
A closer look: Pair them with a chunky colouring book with thick outlines: younger children find big shapes far more satisfying to fill than fine detail. The leads are made for high breakage strength, so they cope with children still learning how hard to press.
Best for: Young children
- Colours
- 24
- Comes in
- Card pack
- Extras
- None

#6STAEDTLER Noris Colour Pencils (24 colours)
Under £10
- Soft non-slip coating
- Break-resistant leads
- Hexagonal, won’t roll away
- Card pack, no case
Tough, bright and pre-sharpened, so they’re ready straight from the pack. The leads are made to resist breaking, and the upcycled wood comes from sustainably managed, certified forests; Staedtler makes them in Germany.
What owners say: Owners find the colours strong and the leads tough enough not to crumble when sharpened, and use them for school work and adult colouring books alike. Opinions split on the leads: some find them soft, others too hard.
A closer look: Their soft, grippy coating makes them easier for small hands to hold than glossy pencils, which is why they suit children just starting to colour inside the lines. The hexagonal barrels also stop them rolling off a desk.
Best for: A non-slip grip
- Colours
- 24
- Comes in
- Card pack
- Extras
- None
Side by side
How they compare
Swipe sideways or rotate device to see all 6.
| Feature | #1Faber-Castell 60 | #2Faber-Castell Polychromos 24 | #3BIC Kids Evolution 24 | #4Melifluo 73 | #5Crayola 24 | #6STAEDTLER Noris 24 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best overall | Best premium | Best budget | ||||
| Picked Rating | 9.3 | 9.6 | 9.4 | 9.2 | 9.2 | 9.2 |
| Price | £22.95 RRP | £30–£50 | Under £10 | £10–£20 | Under £10 | Under £10 |
| Colours | 60, incl. neon, metallic, pastel | 24 (artist grade) | 24 | 72 | 24 | 24 |
| Comes in | Stand-up box | Metal tin | – | Zipped case | Card pack | Card pack |
| Extras | None | None | None | Colouring book | None | None |
| Best for | Metallics | Artists | No splinters | Colouring book in the box | Young children | A non-slip grip |
| Buy now | Amazon | Amazon | Amazon | Amazon | Amazon | Amazon |
How we checked these
How 29 became 6
We found 29 colouring pencil set listings. Five were the same pencils again in a smaller or bigger pack, and eight had too few ratings to compete. That left 16, which we narrowed down step by step:
- Ratings, reviews and salesFor the 16, we then checked the ratings and reviews further, and how many people buy each one. Owners talked most, by far, about leads that break or sharpen badly. After these checks, we dropped three more.13 left
- Features weighed upThe 13 left were compared on the number of colours, what they come in and extras like a colouring book. Once everything was weighed up together, we dropped seven more. The #1 has every feature you’d expect from a colouring pencil set.6 made the cut
- Value for moneyEvery colouring pencil set here is worth what it costs. A dearer one is only here if it gives you more.
Spotted a mistake or something out of date? Tell usBack to top







