Top 5 compared

The best sandwich toasters

Crisp outside, melted in the middle and the filling sealed in: sandwich toasters that turn out a proper toastie in minutes.

21 checked · 5 made the cut

Updated 26 October 2026 · How they compare

An open stainless steel sandwich toaster with two golden cheese toasties inside, beside a bowl of tomato soup on a white kitchen worktop

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. It costs you nothing extra. How this works

The top 5 at a glance

  1. Toastie maker, on a British kitchen worktop with a plate of toasties beside it, a window behind#1Best overall Breville Ultimate Deep Fill £36.998.8/10
  2. Sandwich maker, on a small kitchen table next to a loaf and a block of cheese#2 Tower Deep Fill £23.998.7/10
  3. Sandwich toaster, on a family kitchen island beside a plate of cut toasties#3 Global Gourmet 4-slice £24.998.7/10
  4. Quest sandwich toaster, on the worktop of a student kitchen#4Best budget Quest 35630 £30.508.7/10
  5. Russell Hobbs Creations sandwich maker, on the worktop of a family kitchen#5 Russell Hobbs 3-in-1 £56.998.3/10

A sandwich toaster, or toastie maker, closes two hot plates round a sandwich and toasts both sides at once. The deep-fill kind presses the bread into pockets and cuts each sandwich into two triangles, crimping the edges shut. Some machines also take swappable plates for waffles or a grill plate for paninis.

Fixed plates are wiped clean in place once they’ve cooled, while plates that unclip can go in the dishwasher. Most here stand on end or tuck their cord away, so they fit in a cupboard between uses, and a toastie maker earns that space on the first cold lunchtime. For the crispest finish, butter the outside of the bread.

What matters

  • A latch that locks the lid down while it cooks.
  • Plates that come off, so cheese doesn’t bake on.

#1

Best overall

8.8/10Picked Rating

Toastie maker, on a British kitchen worktop with a plate of toasties beside it, a window behind
Illustrative image

#1Breville Ultimate Deep Fill Toastie Maker (VST082)

£36.99 RRP

Best overall

8.8/10Picked Rating

  • Dishwasher-safe removable plates
  • Extra-deep plates, 20% more room
  • Stands upright to store

Extra-deep plates, with 20% more room than any other Breville toastie maker, press each sandwich into two sealed triangles, and the plates unclip for the dishwasher afterwards. The Breville name has been tied to toasties since its first sealed sandwich toaster in 1974.

What owners say: Owners rave about the ham and cheese toasties it turns out, and like lifting the plates out to wash them.

A closer look: Small and large slices both fit, so there’s no need to trim the bread. Let the plates cool fully before unclipping them for the dishwasher, and make sure each one clicks back into place before the next toastie, so the lid closes flat and the edges seal. Breville’s VST079 waffle plates fit it too, sold separately.

Best for: Small or large slices

Power
850W
Removable plates
Dishwasher-safe
Other plates
Waffle, sold separately
Locks shut
Yes

#2

8.7/10Picked Rating

Sandwich maker, on a small kitchen table next to a loaf and a block of cheese
Illustrative image

#2Tower Deep Fill Sandwich Maker (T27013)

£23.99 RRP

8.7/10Picked Rating

  • Three-year guarantee if registered
  • Deep-fill plates seal toasties
  • Cool-touch housing

A no-fuss 900W toastie maker with four deep pocket moulds for two sealed sandwiches, and a thermostat that keeps the plates at an even heat. Tower began in Wolverhampton as a metal-spinning firm, Midland Metal Spinners.

What owners say: Owners say it browns the bread beautifully, and find the red and green lights make it simple to get right.

A closer look: Wait for the ready light before the sandwich goes in, then latch the lid so the ridges between the pockets cut and seal each toastie cleanly. Registering it online after buying adds two years to Tower’s standard one-year guarantee.

Best for: 3-year guarantee

Power
900W
Removable plates
No
Other plates
None
Locks shut
Yes

#3

8.7/10Picked Rating

Sandwich toaster, on a family kitchen island beside a plate of cut toasties
Illustrative image

#3Global Gourmet by Sensio 4-Slice Sandwich Toaster

£24.99 RRP

8.7/10Picked Rating

  • Deep-fill plates seal the edges
  • Cord stores under the base

Its plates are deeper than many standard models’, leaving room for extra cheese or vegetables, and shaped pockets seal the edges so the filling stays tucked in. The ‘4 slice’ means four slices of bread: two full toasties at a time.

What owners say: Owners find it heats up fast and copes well with all sorts of fillings.

A closer look: Two toasties per round suits a quick lunch for two, with a second batch going in straight after. When it’s cool, a wipe with a damp cloth is all the plates ask for, and the cord winds away under the housing before it goes back in the cupboard.

Best for: Generous fillings

Power
900W
Removable plates
No
Other plates
None
Locks shut
Yes

#4

Best budget

8.7/10Picked Rating

Quest sandwich toaster, on the worktop of a student kitchen
Illustrative image

#4Quest Deep-Fill Sandwich Toaster (35630)

£30.50 RRP

Best budget

8.7/10Picked Rating

  • Deep-fill plates seal toasties
  • Stands upright to store
  • Short 0.7m cord

A stainless steel toastie maker with a thermostat that holds the heat steady, black cool-touch handles and a locking clip. Quest pitches it at student kitchens, and it stands on end to save cupboard space.

What owners say: Owners say it feels solidly built and turns out evenly cooked, crisp toasties.

A closer look: Heat it until the ready light comes on, then close the lid and fasten the locking clip so the edges seal. Once it’s cool, wipe the non-stick plates with a soft cloth rather than anything abrasive, and keep it near a socket, as the cable is on the short side.

Best for: Cost friendly

Power
900W
Removable plates
No
Other plates
None
Locks shut
Yes

#5

8.3/10Picked Rating

Russell Hobbs Creations sandwich maker, on the worktop of a family kitchen
Illustrative image

#5Russell Hobbs Creations 3-in-1 Sandwich Maker (26810)

£56.99 RRP

8.3/10Picked Rating

  • Waffle and grill plates included
  • Dishwasher-safe removable plates
  • Three-year guarantee if registered

Three sets of plates in one machine: deep-fill toasties, waffles and a grill plate for paninis, each clipping out for the dishwasher. Russell Hobbs rates its non-stick coating as three times as durable as an older model’s.

What owners say: Owners say it feels well made and warms up quickly, and they’re glad the plates come out for washing.

A closer look: Change plates only once the machine has cooled right down, and keep the two spare sets together in a drawer or the original box so none go missing. The grill plate is the one for ciabatta and paninis, which are too chunky to seal in the toastie pockets.

Best for: Grilling paninis

Power
750W
Removable plates
Dishwasher-safe
Other plates
Waffle and grill, included
Locks shut
Yes

Side by side

How they compare

Swipe sideways or rotate device to see all 5.

Feature#1Breville Ultimate Deep Fill#2Tower Deep Fill#3Global Gourmet 4-slice#4Quest 35630#5Russell Hobbs 3-in-1
Best overallBest budget
Picked Rating8.88.78.78.78.3
Price£36.99 RRP£23.99 RRP£24.99 RRP£30.50 RRP£56.99 RRP
Power850W900W900W900W750W
Removable plates Dishwasher-safeNoNoNo Dishwasher-safe
Other platesWaffle, sold separatelyNoneNoneNoneWaffle and grill, included
Locks shutYesYesYesYesYes
Best forSmall or large slices3-year guaranteeGenerous fillingsCost friendlyGrilling paninis
Buy nowAmazon Amazon Amazon Amazon Amazon

How we checked these

How 21 became 5

We found 21 sandwich toaster listings. Twelve were rated too low and/or had too few ratings or sales to compete. That left nine, which we narrowed down step by step:

  • Ratings, reviews and salesFor the nine, we then checked the ratings and reviews further, and how many people buy each one. Owners talked most about the size of the plates, then how long they last. After these checks, we dropped two more. Some owners of one of them said it stopped working after its second use.7 left
  • Features weighed upThe seven left were compared on power, removable plates, other plates and whether they lock shut. Once everything was weighed up together, we dropped two more. The Russell Hobbs is here too because it is the only one on the list that comes with waffle and grill plates. The #1 has every feature you’d expect from a sandwich toaster.5 made the cut
  • Value for moneyEvery sandwich toaster here is worth what it costs. A dearer one is only here if it gives you more.
  • Safe to buyEvery brand on this list was checked for safety recalls. None of these five sandwich toasters has one.
No brand paid to be hereEvery sandwich toaster earned its place. We never take money to include a product.

Spotted a mistake or something out of date? Tell usBack to top

Our images are a mix of our own illustrations and Amazon’s listing photos. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. It costs you nothing extra. Certain content that appears on this site comes from Amazon. This content is provided ‘as is’ and is subject to change or removal at any time. How we pick · How this works.