Top 5 compared
The best sketching pencils
Sketches, shading and finished portraits, with pencils that go from fine lines to deep, soft blacks.
36 checked · 5 made the cut

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. It costs you nothing extra. How this works
The top 5 at a glance
Sketching pencils are graphite pencils in a spread of grades. H grades are hard, for pale, crisp guide lines; B grades are soft, for darker shading that gets blacker as the number climbs, with HB in the middle. Sets come as pencils on their own, often in a tin, or as kits that add erasers, a sharpener, blending stumps and charcoal.
Most sets here run from hard grades at one end to very soft ones at the other, so there’s a pencil for each stage of a drawing, from the first faint lines to the darkest shadows. Soft grades wear down faster than hard ones and need sharpening more often.
What matters
- Leads that don’t snap when sharpened.
- The grade printed clearly on every pencil.
- A tin or zipped case that keeps the grades in order.

#1Faber-Castell Castell 9000 Art Set (12 pencils in a tin)
£21.50 RRP
- Six-sided barrels
- Comes in a metal tin
Twelve green pencils in grades from a pale 2H to a velvety 8B, kept in a tin that lives happily in a school bag. The six-sided barrels sit firmly in the hand and won’t roll off a desk. Faber-Castell first made the Castell 9000 in 1905.
What owners say: Owners find the leads smooth, easy to sharpen and good at keeping their point, and like how well the grades blend and how smart the tin looks.
A closer look: A sharp craft knife gives a longer point than a sharpener, which helps when you shade with the side of the lead. Try the grades side by side on a scrap of your drawing paper first: a strip of swatches from 2H to 8B shows you at a glance which pencil gives which tone.
Best for: Not rolling off the desk
- Pencils
- 12, 8B to 2H
- Extras
- Tin only

#2STAEDTLER Mars Lumograph Drawing Pencils (tin of 6, 8B–HB)
Under £10
- Break-resistant bonded leads
- Comes in a metal tin
- No H grades for guide lines
Five soft grades from 4B down to a deep 8B, plus an HB: the set for someone who loves dark, moody shading and portraits. The bonded leads are made to resist snapping when sharpened.
What owners say: Owners say the graphite is smooth and the leads don’t break when sharpened, and use the set for all sorts of drawing.
A closer look: Soft 6B–8B graphite smudges easily, so rest your hand on a scrap of paper as you work, and blend with a tissue or paper stump rather than a fingertip, which leaves grease on the page. Slip a sheet of paper over finished drawings in a sketchbook so they don’t rub onto the facing page.
Best for: Leads that don't snap
- Pencils
- 6, 8B to HB
- Extras
- Tin only

#3YSLON Sketch and Drawing Pencils (tin of 12, 8B–2H)
Under £10
- Hard metal tin protects points
Twelve grades from a hard 2H through H, F and HB to a soft 8B, in a hard metal tin that protects the points in a bag: the full spread of a classic set from a less familiar name, for students and anyone starting to shade.
What owners say: Owners rate the build and the good mix of hard and soft pencils, say the set does just what it promises, and recommend it to beginners and experienced artists alike.
A closer look: Use the F pencil, which sits between HB and H, for crisp outlines that won’t smudge as you shade around them. Sharpen the soft B grades gently by hand rather than in an electric sharpener, as their leads are the easiest to snap.
Best for: The F grade
- Pencils
- 12, 8B to 2H
- Extras
- Tin only

#4Faber-Castell Pitt Graphite Set (tin of 26)
£30–£50
- Erasers, stump and sharpener included
- Water-soluble pencils for washes
- Soft grades down to 9B
Every kind of graphite in one tin: Castell 9000 pencils from 2H to 8B, chunky Jumbo pencils, woodless Pitt Graphite Pure pencils and crayons, and water-soluble Graphite Aquarelle pencils that turn to a grey wash under a wet brush, with erasers, a stump and a brush.
What owners say: Owners like the range of pencils, for novices and professionals alike, find it built to last for years, and rate the look of the tin.
A closer look: The sandpaper block in the tin sharpens the chunky crayons and woodless pencils to a chisel edge for broad strokes. Press the kneadable eraser onto an area to lift out soft highlights, and use the eraser pencil for small, sharp ones such as a glint in an eye.
Best for: Graphite washes
- Pencils
- 16, 2H to 9B
- Extras
- 3 crayons, erasers, stump, sharpener, brush, tin

#5HIFORNY 42-Piece Drawing and Sketching Kit
£10–£20
- Charcoal pencils and sticks included
- Erasers, stumps and sharpener included
- Hard grades up to 5H
Graphite and charcoal together, in a zipped canvas case: everything for a sketching class or drawing outdoors, including a woodless pencil, graphite and charcoal sticks, and a pencil extender for the last few centimetres of each pencil.
What owners say: Owners find it good quality, with a wide variety of pencils and tools, and call it a good start for anyone learning to sketch.
A closer look: Charcoal is much messier than graphite, so spray finished charcoal drawings with a fixative. Keep one of the three blending stumps for charcoal only, so its dust doesn’t grey your graphite shading, and try the white charcoal pencil for highlights on toned paper.
Best for: Charcoal drawing
- Pencils
- 12 graphite + 4 charcoal, 5H to 8B
- Extras
- Sticks, stumps, erasers, sharpener, case
Side by side
How they compare
Swipe sideways or rotate device to see all 5.
| Feature | #1Faber-Castell 9000 | #2Staedtler Lumograph 6 | #3YSLON 12-pencil tin | #4Faber-Castell Pitt Graphite 26 | #5HIFORNY 42-piece |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best overall | Best budget | ||||
| Picked Rating | 9.6 | 9.5 | 9.4 | 9.4 | 9.3 |
| Price | £21.50 RRP | Under £10 | Under £10 | £30–£50 | £10–£20 |
| Pencils | 12, 8B to 2H | 6, 8B to HB | 12, 8B to 2H | 16, 2H to 9B | 12 graphite + 4 charcoal, 5H to 8B |
| Extras | Tin only | Tin only | Tin only | 3 crayons, erasers, stump, sharpener, brush, tin | Sticks, stumps, erasers, sharpener, case |
| Best for | Not rolling off the desk | Leads that don't snap | The F grade | Graphite washes | Charcoal drawing |
| Buy now | Amazon | Amazon | Amazon | Amazon | Amazon |
How we checked these
How 36 became 5
We found 36 sketching pencil set listings. One was a smaller pack of the same pencils, and 14 had too few ratings or sales to compete. That left 21, which we narrowed down step by step:
- Ratings, reviews and salesFor the 21, we then checked the ratings and reviews further, and how many people buy each one. Owners talked most about value for money and whether the leads break, then the range of grades. After these checks, we dropped two more.19 left
- Sold newTwo were dropped because one was only offered used and the other couldn’t be bought when we checked.17 left
- Features weighed upThe 17 left were compared on the pencils in each set and what else comes with them. Once everything was weighed up together, we dropped 12 more.5 made the cut
- Value for moneyEvery sketching pencil set here is worth what it costs. A dearer one is only here if it gives you more.
- Safe to buyEvery brand on this list was checked for safety recalls. None of these five sets has one.
Spotted a mistake or something out of date? Tell usBack to top





