How we do it

Everything on Picked Properly goes through the same steps. Here’s how we choose products, rate them, compare them and match them to the people you’re buying for.

How we pick

For each kind of product we start by gathering every listing, beginning with what people actually buy, and keep buying, rather than whatever is being advertised that week.

We then set aside anything that doesn’t belong: a different kind of product, something sold from abroad or hard to get, or anything with a safety recall. We read the rest: what owners say, the specifications and, where they exist, independent expert reviews. Anything with a pattern of problems gets left out, however popular it is.

We don’t test products ourselves. Every pick is researched, and most lists end with a box showing how we narrowed them down, from every listing to the final few.

The Picked Rating

We work out a Picked Rating out of 10, our own score, for every listing we look at, not just the ones that make the list. It starts from how owners rate it. A product with only a few ratings is marked down until more owners have had their say, and complaints cost marks, with faults and breakages counting for more than smaller gripes. How well it does the main jobs for its kind of product, judged from its specifications, can add or take away marks. A shortfall found by an independent expert review costs marks, and a product that far outsells the rest gets a small lift. The products you see on a list are our final selections.

The list runs in Picked Rating order, with one exception. Our #1, the Best overall, is the highest-rated product that does the main job fully for most buyers, has every feature you’d expect and isn’t priced well above what it needs to be. A niche or cut-down version, or one that costs more than most people need to spend, can rate higher but sits below it.

Comparing the picks

Once the research has narrowed everything down to the best few, each top list gives you all you need to compare them yourself. It opens with what matters for that kind of product, then the picks at a glance. Each product shows its Picked Rating, a Best for line saying what it’s best at or who it suits, its pros and cons and its key features, and badges mark the Best overall, the Best budget and the Best premium. At the end, a table lines up the features that matter side by side, and a box shows how we narrowed every listing down to the final few. Tap the heart on any product to save it to your gift list and share it.

The gift finder

Think of the gift finder as every one of our final selections shaken together and sorted for one person. Every product that made a top list or a gift guide goes in, apart from things that aren’t really gifts, like a fridge, and each one is tagged with who it suits and what it’s for. Tell the finder who you’re buying for, your budget and, if you like, their interests, and it sifts the lot down to the ones that fit. A product that suits the person and their interests comes first, and close matches are ordered by their Picked Rating. Every suggestion links back to its top list, so you can see how it stacks up against the rest.

Gift guides

Our gift guides are hand-picked ideas for a particular person or occasion. Each idea comes with a pick, usually from one of our top lists, so it has been through the same checks.